In the below conversation with AI: “Walid” is when I asked Claude 3.5, then it answered in “Claude” section.
I had a conversation with AI “Claude 3.5” regarding IFRS 16 and the requirement to capitalize leased assets by debiting right of use assets and crediting a liability. Although, I encourage all accountants to apply accounting standards, still I find it necessary to discuss conceptual theories in accounting.
Historically, we had operating lease and financing or capital lease. The main rules were used ambiguously by many to record most or all the company leases as operating leases. Then, IFRS 16 came out requiring capitalizing all or most leases as right of use.
To give you a little background, for me it started during my studies for my masters in accounting in 2010, when I had a course on accounting theory. In this course I researched IFRS 16 new proposal regarding financing lease or capital lease new rule as opposed to operating lease that was misused at that time.
After my research I came up with a suggestion that was midway between the operating leases (abused) old standard, and the new all leases capitalised (enforced) standard. My suggestion was and still is to enforce the lessee to capitalize the assets that are used directly in generating revenues to the company, while keeping assets used in “sales general and admin” as operating or financing without enforcing the capitalization clause.
This is different from IFRS 16 that came later with a requirement for the lessee to capitalize all / most assets that are leased regardless of the use.
In short, the theory is that companies will capitalize all factories, equipment, machinery and planes for airlines or shops for retailers or similar. The reason is that the company cannot function without these essential assets that generate the revenues. While the company can function without admin cars by having deliveries and they can rent the headquarters offices or work from home (nowadays). So, companies need not invest in inessential assets, but if they do then they capitalize them.
So, I asked Claude about its opinion on the matter and here is the brief:
Do you know about IFRS 16 leasing of assets?
Yes, I'm familiar with IFRS 16, which is the International Financial Reporting Standard that deals with the accounting for leases. Here are some key points about IFRS 16:
Please elaborate on IFRS 16 eliminating the distinction between operating and finance leases for lessees. Now, most leases are recognized on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability as compared to previous method.
Certainly, I'd be happy to elaborate on this key change introduced by IFRS 16.
Previous method…: Before IFRS 16, leases were classified as either operating leases or finance leases:
New method (under IFRS 16): IFRS 16 introduced a single lessee accounting model:
Key differences and implications: ….
What is the argument against recording all leases as right to use and liability?
There are several arguments against recording all leases as right-of-use assets and liabilities. Here are some of the main points:
in the same spirit of the above let us consider separating "revenue generating assets" that are used in production of "the products or services that the company sells" and assets used in other business operations "sales general and admin". Is there a merit to this among accountants or authorities?
This is an interesting concept you're proposing, and it touches on some fundamental principles of accounting and financial reporting. While there isn't a widespread practice of explicitly separating assets in financial statements exactly as you've described, there are some related concepts and discussions in accounting circles. Let's explore this idea:
While there isn't a widespread movement to adopt this specific categorization in formal financial reporting, the idea aligns with the ongoing efforts to make financial statements more informative and useful for decision-making. As financial reporting continues to evolve, we might see more granular and purpose-oriented asset classifications in the future.
If you're interested in exploring this concept further, you might want to look into academic accounting journals or professional accounting bodies' research publications, where such ideas are often discussed and debated.
This is another article in the series titled Conversations with AI. It…
This article is a continuation of the Conversations with AI series. In…
This article is about qualities that leaders need to succeed in governance.…
This article is about AI Governance while chatting with one of most famous…
© 2024 Meirc Training & Consulting. All rights reserved.